It happened over a glass of something dark and unhurried, sitting on the same distillery porch where I once lost more than a few rounds of dominoes to Otto and Faye, when I realized I'd been drinking my way across two continents for years without ever once stopping to ask the drink in my hand a serious question. I've told you about coffee farmers and cassava fields and a bowl of gumbo old enough to argue about its own parentage, and somewhere in all that careful attention to what I was eating, I let the thing I was drinking alongside it slide by as background noise, just the thing that made the food taste better and the evenings run longer. That never sat right with me once I noticed it, because if there's one substance that's actually followed me the entire length of this whole odyssey, present in some form on every single stop from a rum shop in Barbados to a distillery porch in the Florida Keys, it's rum, and I owe it a closer look.
So here's a new book, a companion of sorts to the food chronicles I've already been writing, except this one follows a single spirit instead of a whole cuisine, back through the islands and the ports and the sugar country that built it. Rum has a strange, split personality that most people who drink it never bother to notice. It's simultaneously the most democratic spirit in the world, distilled from the sugarcane byproducts that plantation workers and enslaved people first fermented out of necessity and desperation, and one of the most fought-over commodities in the history of European colonization, a drink that funded wars, fueled the slave trade directly, floated entire pirate economies, and eventually got smuggled past a fair number of governments who'd decided, at various points, that people shouldn't be allowed to have it. That's a lot of history sitting quietly in a glass most people order without a second thought.
I decided to start this one in Key West, partly because it's the stop I know best on this whole trip and partly because it turns out to be a far better starting point than I gave it credit for the first time through. I went straight back to that same distillery I'd once debated staying at for months, the crew still running the same small operation, still pouring the same rich, barrel-aged pours in the same low-key tasting room out back. What I hadn't paid proper attention to before was the actual reason a rum distillery makes sense on this particular island at all. Key West sits close enough to Cuba that you can practically see the idea drifting over on a clear day, and this whole island built a meaningful piece of its economy, for a good long stretch, on rum that never had any legal business being here.
During Prohibition, when the rest of the country went dry on paper, Key West barely blinked. Boats ran rum up from Cuba and the Bahamas in a nightly parade that locals still talk about with more pride than shame, small fast craft slipping between the shallows and the mangroves, delivering cases of the stuff to docks and back rooms all over the island while federal agents mostly gave up trying to keep pace with a coastline this riddled with hiding places. A bartender at Sloppy Joe's, the same tin-roofed room I'd sat in years before thinking mostly about a certain scruffy troubadour who used to play there, walked me through the whole era while pouring me something considerably better than whatever those Prohibition-era boats were actually smuggling, and told me the island's whole relationship with rum has never really been about refinement. It's been about defiance, about a stretch of land far enough from anybody's capital city to just decide the rules didn't apply and go on drinking anyway.
That defiance runs straight through to what the distillery itself is doing now, small-batch rum finished in old bourbon and port barrels, a genuine attempt to build something with real craft behind it on an island that spent most of its rum history caring a great deal more about supply than quality. I sat with a woman named Delia, no relation to the fishing guide of the same name I'd met on my first pass through, who works the still there, and she told me the hardest part of her job isn't the distilling itself but convincing visitors that rum can be sipped slowly and taken seriously instead of just dumped into whatever's cold and fruity. She poured me a taste finished in a barrel that had held Cuban coffee liqueur before the rum ever touched it, and I understood, sitting there with the ceiling fans turning slow overhead, exactly what she meant.
I don't know yet how far this particular thread is going to pull me, only that it's already tugging hard toward Barbados and Cuba and a distillery in Grenada I remember being told, in passing, was older than the country it sits in. Rum, more than almost anything else I've had a glass of on this whole trip, seems to carry an entire hemisphere's worth of sugar, slavery, smuggling, and stubborn island pride inside every pour, and I intend to follow that thread properly this time instead of just enjoying the buzz and moving on to the next stop. Key West turned out to be exactly the right place to raise the first glass. I've got a long way still to go before I put it down.
Comments